Talk:Madoka Magica Characters

From Puella Magi Wiki
Revision as of 23:44, 25 November 2015 by Sevv (talk | contribs) (Edit War Redux: Nagisa)
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Note: Please always sign your name when editing talk page by putting four tildes (~~~~) at the end of your comment.

Edit war

I'm temporary locking this page before it is turning into a full blown edit war. If you have any particular reasoning behind the changes, please feel free to discuss here. I'll unlock the page once we've reached conclusion on what to do, or a week passed. (Thanks User:AntMan9751 for notifying me) --0x99 05:12, 22 January 2014 (UTC)

Edit War Redux: Nagisa

Would User:Skittylover228 and User:Sevv please pause your edit wars for a moment and have a civilized discussion in the talk page first? I think there're sound reasons both for and against including Momoe Nagisa as part of the main cast, but you two are being unproductive by constantly reverting each other. Talk it out. - Prima 22:41, 25 November 2015 (UTC)

I should've thought of this sooner, whoops. Anyways, my reasoning is that Nagisa shouldn't be a part of the main cast, as she has too little screen time, development, and is too flat/one-dimensional of a character presently. We know next to nothing about her, and the material on her so far outside of Rebellion comes from secondary sources like the production notes (of which there is very little on Nagisa from what I have seen), I think a couple of spin-offs from Kirara Magica (whose canon statuses are very debatable), reading between the lines (which can vary wildly and would be more appropriately considered speculation), and headcanons (same situation). Hitomi and Kyosuke have more screentime and material than Nagisa does, and they're considered secondary characters and not part of the main cast. The only real difference between them and Nagisa is that Nagisa is a magical girl, which, while it gives her more potential and reason to be up in the same spot as the main cast, does not automatically justify it as there is just no substance to her thus far. Sevv 23:44, 25 November 2015 (UTC)