Community:Witches are generated by Magical Girls

This page contains community-made content. As such, it may not otherwise meet editorial or quality standards established elsewhere on the wiki. However, it remains a significant part of the series' history and cultural context and is kept here for archival purposes.

This page is a theory that was made during the original broadcast or during the screening of Rebellion and has since been debunked. The content of this article should not be taken as a fact. It is archived here for the sake of completeness.

There is possibility that the witches are generated by the birth of magical girls. That means the wishes can generate anti-wishes related to magical girls themselves. For example, Mami's enemies are related to flowers, butterfly, desserts. Mami has interests on desserts and she also uses butterfly-like hair clip. The theme color of the witches' lairs is close to Mami's theme color. When Sayaka becomes a magical girl, the witches' lairs change to blue theme color. The stronger wishes generates stronger anti-wishes. As a result, possibly Madoka could generate very powerful witches.

The opposite could also be possible: a human turned into a witch by making a curse generates an "irregular" magical girl with an anti-curse. This would then be why Kyubey can't track Homura; she never accepted the contract.