Talk:The Rebellion Story/Q&A

From Puella Magi Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Note: Please always sign your name when editing talk page by putting four tildes (~~~~) at the end of your comment.

Can anyone who's seen the movie feel free to answer these questions? Heullo 13:29, 9 December 2013 (UTC)

Which ones? This list has answers, although there's quite a bit of misinformation.--Universalperson 16:54, 9 December 2013 (UTC)
I probably should note that this is a fan analysis, which I copied over as requested by the author Special:Contributions/ Feel free to correct any objectively erroneous information. - Prima 17:21, 9 December 2013 (UTC)
Is it worth trying to keep this page updated? A lot of the questions would be better answered in a detailed summary for the main movie page. --Knon 17:39, 10 December 2013 (UTC)
Em... You're right. I guess the better option is aim to eventually retire this page (and The Rebellion Story/Spoiler), and incorporate whatever of value from these pages back into the main The Rebellion Story page. We started these separate pages initially to isolate spoilers for the movie, in anyhow, so their purpose will vanish soon. Maybe we start working on that, once the NA screening tour draws to a close. Thoughts? - Prima 12:31, 11 December 2013 (UTC)
Personally, I would still keep some form of spoiler separation until the BD comes out. But I agree on retiring these pages or at least cleaning them up a little, as The Rebellion Story/Spoiler is going to become quite unwieldy at this rate. --Knon 14:07, 11 December 2013 (UTC)

Issues with the Q&A

I have seen it, and for the answers in some of these questions I feel they aren't correct, for instance, that sayaka, and momoe, in the world homura created are real, due to the fact that homura has the ability to go back in time, and bringing them back, and as soon as Homura as a witch was defeated, this world homura created ceased fell apart, and homura seems have "died" where the incubator's barrier has fallen, the 3 of them madoka, sayaka and momoe has been ported back to their respective place, and this can be confirmed by how incubators always have to purify homura's gem due to the fact that homura let these people in from the past/alternate universe, and creating the world. also the world homura created is "real" in comparison to some people saying it is in her mind. from the end of the series, from the end of the last movie, where madoka turned into godoka, and only puella magi left were kyoko, mami and homura, and in the same old city. at the end of the last movie, homura was telling kyueby how witches used to work, and that is why kyueby somehow started to investigate this what homura said, and locked homura inside their barrier. and in the movie, homura herself is the illusion, not her real body, these are some of my thoughts after watching, and doing some investigations Mapleshilc 06:15, 11 December 2013 (UTC)

This here is mainly the question I was referring to when I wanted to add something. None of the main cast, not even people like Junko, are "dream world replicas." Heullo 09:38, 11 December 2013 (UTC)
Yes exactly, so I dont know if I should edit the Q&A section, but since a lot of the stuff is still up for discussion, the final verdict could always come out when they release the BD for it Mapleshilc 00:47, 12 December 2013 (UTC)
There's too much speculations in the Q&A - it's not a "I think", or "I'm not sure" place. Save that for the speculations page if you aren't sure of the answer (I understand that some question don't really have an answer yet, I understand). Plus, some of the answers were answered by people who doesn't even sound like they have watched the movie to begin with, or people who just wanted to talk about their personal feelings. Sairanac 17:36, 16 December 2013 (UTC)
Why this Q&A haven't been nuked yet, it full of misinterpretation, speculation and contraction, Leaving this be will only cause confusion about the Movie, well, exuse me I'm nuking it, oh and about the replica things it explained CLEARLY in the Movie that the character are the real one that was dragged into Homura Barrier.Kimidori 09:11, 22 December 2013 (UTC)