Speculah talk:Mami is a villain Theory

I believe Mami Tomoe may be a villain due to a couple of things, I apologize if these things may be wrong. First off, I noticed in episode 3, when Madoka was asking for ideas on what to wish for, Mami said "How about this, then? If you haven't thought of a wish by the time we've taken out this witch, how about you wish for a grand feast and a cake from Kyubey?" which I find particularly odd. Yes, I understand she also listed a couple of other things, but Mami is friends with Nagisa, or Charlette the Candy Witch! What did Nagisa wish for? Cake for her dying mother. What if Mami knew Nagisa was going to make the wish but didn't stop her because she didn't care. I believe Mami froze up when she was about to be killed because she realized what she had done. Another thing is when Mami found out the truth about magical girls she instantly resorted to killing everyone, yet this was played off to be shock value. But Mami had witnessed horrible things before? So her finding out this wouldn't be as hard on her? I may be reaching but this is a beloved theory of mine so I want to see how you guys feel about it.M4RY 404 (talk) 04:07, 3 March 2022 (UTC)