User talk:SayakaMadoka

could you please put it on the speculation section then. As part of the observation Madoka seems to waver to do the right thing. However, stated in Episode 11 any wish she makes will be twisted by the nature of the wish. --Mutopis 08:21, 25 September 2011 (UTC)

please restore the link to philosophical observation. While it is true it is speculation, it is part as an attempt to understand the character of Madoka. This is why we have a section regarding speculation --Mutopis 08:25, 25 September 2011 (UTC)

In the future if you think there are some need of changes, do not delete without at least consulting why. We want to keep as much information within the page, even if it is speculation. --Mutopis 08:27, 25 September 2011 (UTC)

I will go ahead and put the deleted sections in speculation since you didnt do it... I guess I will have to do it myself... --Mutopis 08:58, 25 September 2011 (UTC)

quote: "However, I still don't think it's good to say Madoka has become an "adult". In the anime, so called "maturity" is metaphorized as, essentially, corruption." When one becomes an adult, most likely he becomes a minion, a witch or a person whose true heart is blinded that he cannot resonant with other people and the power of the light side(hope, selfless love...). So it's OK to say Madoka grows up as herself but it's not good to say that she has become an adult,"

That is correct when we are talking about witches it is true, but we have to remember the part when Madoka was having a heartfelt conversation with her Mother, in which Junko was telling her that the world of adults was difficult and hard in which making "mistakes" was much more difficult and how children had it easy because mistakes were much more easy to make and heal. Then in Episode 11 we see Madoka is growing and she is understanding that she is stepping into the world of adult responsibility, that she cannot run away from her fears. Madoka is leaving the world of childhood adolescence and taking the mantle of adulthood but unlike witches, she carries with her hopes and dreams that are not immature in nature but very mature. You can be hopeful and mature and still carry it with you to the world of adulthood. Keep in mind, the new world is not perfect, is not an idealized version of a typical mahou shoujo fantasy world, but it is a better world thanks by Madoka's sacrifice. Madoka knowing the responsibilities and needs of this new world tries to keep it in valance. Madoka is taking all of that responsibility as it was stated by Mami's spirit in the final episode, that is one huge responsibility for a child. Madoka wants to emulate her mother and become a better adult and in doing so, rather than become a witch, she became a woman. Madoka also reasserts her adulthood by purifying the witches. She doesnt take away their hopes and dreams, nor does she prevents their death. Like an understanding adult she respect their wishes and purifies their souls so they can be taken wither her. Madoka is not as much as preventing witchfication but taking their burdens and impurities to help them pass on. So Madoka is lending them a helping hand, to all of them, for all eternity. In a way, as you stated it is no differing from the witchification process where the metamorphosis still transformed Madoka, but that doesnt mean adulthood is wrong, it just means that the girls during the second stage of growing became witches because of curses and despair, in Madoka case during the second stage of curse and despair Madoka defeated it by still retaining her purity. Dont forget, Madoka did still became a Witch in Episode 12, but she also became the embodiment of hope and she defeated it. This is a show of a girl growing from childhood adolescence into the early stages of adulthood. --Mutopis 19:28, 25 September 2011 (UTC)