Scene 0 Film 12

Mabayu's's proposal to have Mami join them is rejected by Homura. After that, when she tried to erase Mami's memory of her turning into a witch, she saw in Mami a self she didn't know. It was the memory of the crime of recruiting a girl to become a magical girl, and turning her into a witch while fighting alongside Mami. It was Madoka who saved Mabayu from drowning in the fact that she was the only one who had erased her memories. What she saw in her wish was the lost first first loop and a future where everyone would be saved. In the first loop, Mabayu had erased the memories of magical girls from herself and Kyubey in order to move forward towards that saved future. Mabayu, who know remembers everything, erases her memory and challenges Walpurgisnacht in order to save Mami, and takes on the final time loop.

Summary

Day 1

In the time that goes around, the true wish... where is it?

An alarm rings, waking Mabayu Aki. She wakes up, and immediately begins to ponder what Kyubey had said in the final moments of the last time loop. He had said something about her replacing Madoka, but that's impossible...wasn't it?

As she walked to school, Mabayu was still thinking about it. She had never thought of replacing Madoka; she had only wanted to be able to help Homura. There's nothing else she would want to wish for. No, it was better to just not think about the nonsense the little beast had spouted. What she needed to do was focus on the task at hand: how to defeat Walpurgisnacht. If they ever wanted out of this nightmare, they would need a different approach. Her thoughts are interrupted when Mami Tomoe gets her attention then walks up to her to ask about a book she wanted to borrow. Mabayu screams in fright, before quickly telling her it was nothing. Mabayu apologizes for frightening then runs off, leaving a puzzled Mami standing there in confusion.

Inside the class, Mabayu calms herself down. She normally ignored Mami so her existence had completely slipped from her mind. But she was a magical girl, and a veteran one at that who was more than capable of working on her own. It didn't work before when they tried it with Sayaka and Madoka by their sides, but if they were to add Mami and use her future vision then surely they would get different results!

The first thing Homura does after Mabayu presents her idea is to completely reject it. Mabayu can't understand why not, so Homura explains the reason is because she's a veteran. She's likely to take proactive measures of her own in response to the strange events that occur in the town. Even the slightest change in their behavior can shake up the future immensely, which is why she always made it a point to send Mami out to exterminate witches in another city. Mabayu argues that Homura's point only proves her own point about Mami's prowess as a magical girl. Homura grabs Mabayu's sweater and warns her she won't allow Mami into their group so that's the end of this discussion. Mabayu meekly says she understands, but still reminds her if things stay the same as last time, then there's no chance of their winning. Can Walpurgisnacht really be defeated by just the two of them? Homura asks if she's scared but mabayu promises it's not that. She begins to speak and immediately trails off into silence. Homura prompts her after a moment of silence. Mabayu continues to think to herself before suddenly getting an idea. Rather than use Mami, they could add someone else to their team.

Day 5

Day 6

Day 7

Day 11

(There are no scenes in the main story for Day 11).

Scene 1 (Kyoko)
Sayaka and Kyoko thank each other in anticipation for their hard work today at the café. Sayaka introduces herself as this is her first day on the job. Now that she's the senior, Kyoko decides to leave it all to Sayaka while she puts her feet up but Sayaka tells her to hold on. She literally just started so she has no idea how to serve customers and was relying on Kyoko to teach her. Kyoko sighs heavily as she complains about the annoyance of the situation. Sayaka begs her senpai once more to teach her but Kyoko tells her to stop calling her that. She herself only started part-timing here earlier this week, but according to Sayaka a senpai is a senpai whether it be by a day or a second. Kyoko calls it tedious.

Day 14

(There are no scenes in the main story for Day 14).

Scene 2 (Kyoko)
The customer at the café asks for the check, but Sayaka ignores her as she stands lost in her own thoughts. The customer tries once more to get her attention, and when that fails, Mabayu calls out she's on her way. She brings her her bill for 1,000 yen which the girl promptly pays for. Mabayu thanks her as the girl leaves. It seems Sayaka has now come out of her daze as she thanks the girl as well, although Kyoko wonders aloud why she's bothering. Inwardly, Kyoko recalls that Homura had warned her Sayaka had the potential to contract, and would most likely meet with Kyubey soon. She shakes off the thought and clarifies her earlier statement, asking why Sayaka is bothering with a part-time job. Is it the money that she needs and what will she do once the school finds out? Why else would she be working secretly unless perhaps she was homeless? Sayaka flatly denies this explanation, weakly responding she simply wanted to work there but Kyoko isn't buying it. She thinks if Sayaka needed the money, she could very easily just take it. Kyoko doesn't know what she's gotten herself in to, but it doesn't matter.

Day 15

Day 16

Day 17

Scene 3 (Kyoko)
Sayaka puffs to herself happily as she hears the bell on the café door ring. She greets them automatically and offers them a seat. She notices Kyoko staring at her and asks what's up. But Kyoko has no answer, for once it seems Sayaka's feeling in a pretty good mood. Like she'd dropped the anxiety from a burden. Sayaka says it's because she'd had some high hopes and it's like she'd been blinded by her desires. But even so, she's still herself after all. She thinks it's important to keep yourself grounded, so as long as she's able to help someone then that's enough for her. She blinks as she realizes she's gone off track and maybe this isn't what Kyoko was talking about. Kyoko doesn't get it, but that's ok. People who claim to be doing it for the sake of others are a dime a dozen when most of the time they're just getting off on how good they look to others. Sayaka smiles and calls her words poisonous, but Kyoko doesn't see what's wrong with that. If you're going to go down because of someone else, they just become a burden so it's better to be sincere in your desires and pursue what you truly want. Sayaka laughs; that's just like Kyoko-senpai to say such things, but maybe Kyoko should curb her appetites a bit. Kyoko claims it's not her fault Sakie makes such delicious cakes. She suddenly hears Homura's voice through telepathy, demanding she come to her house right away. Kyoko tries to explain she's in the middle of her shift, but Homura insists there isn't time and urges her on once more.