User talk:SerenDark
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
I want to apologize. I was having a bad day earlier and I took it out on you. It is still Tart, not Minou. However, I had no reason to insult you. I am sorry. Amaterasu (talk) 00:59, 4 October 2023 (UTC)
- No worries. However, I made the changes after seeing a conversation where people were talking about how the art was mistakenly labelled as including Tart. Tart does make more sense considering Elisa and Liz are there, however the Japanese characters in the image by the girl in question are the same as for Minou's name (ミヌゥ), her facial expression with the furrowed brow and kind of sultry look is much closer to Minou than Tart's own disposition, and while admittedly this isn't my favorite detail to use as evidence, "Tart was never that well endowed; this is even pointed out in the first chapter of the manga". Minou and Tart do look rather similar, but I really don't think this is Tart. I think it's Minou, especially considering the ミヌゥ.
- EDIT: I have been additionally informed that the context behind this illustration is, quite literally: "it just says "tart gacha rerun promotion relying on 'milkbreast fat content'". I guess the difference between Minou and Tart's chest sizes may indeed be quite relevant for the theming behind this image.
- This is my first time replying on a page such as this on a wiki, my apologies if I didn't do it correctly. SerenDark (talk)
- I see your point on the subject here. I do think it is Tart in the illustration, but I do see where you are coming from. However, the main part I see is the hair. Tart and Minou's hair is styled differently, so I think that is the main argument for "This is Tart". (Also, messing up on a talk page isnt a big deal here. You can still learn, after all!) Amaterasu (talk) 12:57, 4 October 2023 (UTC)
- How are they styled differently? From what I can tell, the only notable difference between Tart and Minou is the colour of their hair. The styles are pretty much identical. You can notice some minor differences if you look closely (Tart's hair flares out a bit more at the end, at least when comparing the Magia Record Live2D models), but they're not at a level that I'd be comfortable using them to distinguish the two. ~ Celtic Minstrel (talk) 17:51, 4 October 2023 (UTC)
- (Oh, and I also think the fact that she's literally labelled "Minou" in the art should be a pretty strong deciding factor on this question.) ~ Celtic Minstrel (talk) 17:53, 4 October 2023 (UTC)
- I see your point on the subject here. I do think it is Tart in the illustration, but I do see where you are coming from. However, the main part I see is the hair. Tart and Minou's hair is styled differently, so I think that is the main argument for "This is Tart". (Also, messing up on a talk page isnt a big deal here. You can still learn, after all!) Amaterasu (talk) 12:57, 4 October 2023 (UTC)