Talk:Scene 0 Film 0: Difference between revisions

From Puella Magi Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page with "Do we really need random screenshots from the 2011 anime and all the Live2D models? The screenshots are confusing, since they're not from Scene0, and the Live2D models (at least the ones that were already in the game beforehand, it does feel kiiiind of different with new ones like the maid uniforms) just beg the question... why? Everyone should know what Homura in her school uniform looks like. Add a note in the summary what everyone's wearing, if it's that important. I'...")
 
No edit summary
 
(3 intermediate revisions by one other user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Do we really need random screenshots from the 2011 anime and all the Live2D models? The screenshots are confusing, since they're not from Scene0, and the Live2D models (at least the ones that were already in the game beforehand, it does feel kiiiind of different with new ones like the maid uniforms) just beg the question... why? Everyone should know what Homura in her school uniform looks like. Add a note in the summary what everyone's wearing, if it's that important. I'm fine with CGs and the witches, especially the more obscure ones, staying. But the rest just invites clutter. Even making those images smaller, like into <nowiki><gallery></nowiki> would make it feel less bloated. [[User:EPF|EPF]] ([[User talk:EPF|talk]]) 07:33, 24 March 2024 (UTC)
Do we really need random screenshots from the 2011 anime and all the Live2D models? The screenshots are confusing, since they're not from Scene0, and the Live2D models (at least the ones that were already in the game beforehand, it does feel kiiiind of different with new ones like the maid uniforms) just beg the question... why? Everyone should know what Homura in her school uniform looks like. Add a note in the summary what everyone's wearing, if it's that important. I'm fine with CGs and the witches, especially the more obscure ones, staying. But the rest just invites clutter. Even making those images smaller, like into <nowiki><gallery></nowiki> would make it feel less bloated. [[User:EPF|EPF]] ([[User talk:EPF|talk]]) 07:33, 24 March 2024 (UTC)
:I threw in the images because otherwise it's a GIANT ass wall of text for days on end that's hard on the eyes. I got some feedback from different groups asking me to throw in a few more pictures and make the ones I had a little bigger (and centered them into a gallery type mode). Even if they're not strictly in Scene 0, many of the scenes are lifted directly from the anime so I thought it would also be helpful for context to the readers as a sort of "ohh, I know what scene this is". Also, I put in the live2D where it was first shown in that film instead of showing what they're wearing for every single scene. I can take them out, but the reader in theory wouldn't know when Sayaka started to wear her casual clothes instead of just her school uniform. [[User:Sondenise|Sondenise]] ([[User talk:Sondenise|talk]]) 15:04, 24 March 2024 (UTC)
::I agree with the addition of the SS's and L2D's. It makes the section more readable and helps the reader visualize what is going on. [[User:Amaterasu|Amaterasu]] ([[User talk:Amaterasu|talk]]) 12:30, 25 March 2024 (UTC)

Latest revision as of 12:30, 25 March 2024

Do we really need random screenshots from the 2011 anime and all the Live2D models? The screenshots are confusing, since they're not from Scene0, and the Live2D models (at least the ones that were already in the game beforehand, it does feel kiiiind of different with new ones like the maid uniforms) just beg the question... why? Everyone should know what Homura in her school uniform looks like. Add a note in the summary what everyone's wearing, if it's that important. I'm fine with CGs and the witches, especially the more obscure ones, staying. But the rest just invites clutter. Even making those images smaller, like into <gallery> would make it feel less bloated. EPF (talk) 07:33, 24 March 2024 (UTC)

I threw in the images because otherwise it's a GIANT ass wall of text for days on end that's hard on the eyes. I got some feedback from different groups asking me to throw in a few more pictures and make the ones I had a little bigger (and centered them into a gallery type mode). Even if they're not strictly in Scene 0, many of the scenes are lifted directly from the anime so I thought it would also be helpful for context to the readers as a sort of "ohh, I know what scene this is". Also, I put in the live2D where it was first shown in that film instead of showing what they're wearing for every single scene. I can take them out, but the reader in theory wouldn't know when Sayaka started to wear her casual clothes instead of just her school uniform. Sondenise (talk) 15:04, 24 March 2024 (UTC)
I agree with the addition of the SS's and L2D's. It makes the section more readable and helps the reader visualize what is going on. Amaterasu (talk) 12:30, 25 March 2024 (UTC)