User talk:Sondenise: Difference between revisions

From Puella Magi Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(→‎Memoria cards: new section)
Line 21: Line 21:


# Is there some logic to how memoria cards are ordered on a character's page? Is it just alphabetical by name?
# Is there some logic to how memoria cards are ordered on a character's page? Is it just alphabetical by name?
:I try to sort them by alphabetical order. [[User:Sondenise|Sondenise]] ([[User talk:Sondenise|talk]]) 01:35, 10 April 2022 (UTC)
# What's the best way to deal with alternate versions of characters, and dual units?
# What's the best way to deal with alternate versions of characters, and dual units?
#:Should a memoria featuring swimsuit Iroha be included on Iroha's main page?
#:Should a memoria featuring swimsuit Iroha be included on Iroha's main page?
Line 30: Line 31:
#:Should a memoria featuring doppel Kyouko be featured on Kyouko's main page?
#:Should a memoria featuring doppel Kyouko be featured on Kyouko's main page?
#:I imagine this is a complex question... my instinct would suggest the answer be "no" in the case of Iroha-chan or Ultimate Madoka but "yes" in most of the other cases.
#:I imagine this is a complex question... my instinct would suggest the answer be "no" in the case of Iroha-chan or Ultimate Madoka but "yes" in most of the other cases.
 
: Originally I tended to leave the memoria unique to the alternate units on their respective page if only because some units have so many alts or are featured in so many memoria that it would really increase the page length. That said, maybe we should move their memorias to their own page or put it under a collapsible table to help cut down on the page length. If we do it like that, then I would agree that we should include their alt version memorias on their vanilla unit page with the exception of the PAPA units since those guys are basically their own universe and fairly self-contained.
Also, based on this new [[:Category:Magia Record Memoria Cards]] and comparing the count with the other Magia Record wiki, there seems to be one card entirely missing. I have no way to determine which one it could be, though, as the category is sorted by filename and the filenames are all over the place.
Also, based on this new [[:Category:Magia Record Memoria Cards]] and comparing the count with the other Magia Record wiki, there seems to be one card entirely missing. I have no way to determine which one it could be, though, as the category is sorted by filename and the filenames are all over the place.
: I wonder how we could track it down. If there's a way of tagging or letting me know which ones need to be renamed to their original file names I'm willing to move them all for the sake of uniformity and so we can track down that last memoria and get it up on the site. [[User:Sondenise|Sondenise]] ([[User talk:Sondenise|talk]]) 01:35, 10 April 2022 (UTC)


One last thing: I found three card images that are duplicates. In particular, this one exists in both JPEG and WEBP format for some reason:
One last thing: I found three card images that are duplicates. In particular, this one exists in both JPEG and WEBP format for some reason:
Line 39: Line 41:
File:Memoria_10001_c.webp|WEBP
File:Memoria_10001_c.webp|WEBP
</gallery>
</gallery>
:This is probably a case where more than one person uploaded the image and then since it's different formats they didn't get the warning. I can delete the extra file, just tag the one you want me to delete with the deletion tag.
: Since you are going through the memorias, do you think it would be too much to add a tag for the passive/active memos and another tag for 1*,2*, 3*,4*?
:On another note entirely, since we now have the "akuma" typing for magireco, would it be possible to write the template so we have an "other" typing and then put a "|displayname=" where it just displays a name for the typing but it's still categorized as "other"? I think this might take care of the one off types like Nagisa, Nagisa alt, Ult. Madoka-senpai and one or two i've forgotten.
:Thank you very much for you hard work and lemme know what I can do to help. [[User:Sondenise|Sondenise]] ([[User talk:Sondenise|talk]]) 01:35, 10 April 2022 (UTC)

Revision as of 01:35, 10 April 2022

Why was the page Mami's mammies deleted?

Hi there, I am not sure if this is the correct place to ask this. Sometimes I go to the Mami's mammies to grab some images to use or just to link to it as a joke in the /r/MadokaMagica Discord Server for newer people that don't know it exists. Except this time when I checked I saw that it was deleted by you, was there a specific reason for this? I, and others, thought it was quite a funny meme in the community so it would be a bit sad to see it go from the wiki after all these years.

Greetings,

Mhykol (you can also contact me on Discord: Mhykol Eclipsed#2024 or just in the MadokaMagica Discord server)

Hello there. While I personally find the page to also be amusing and mostly harmless, there was previous talk about deleting the page and recently when it was brought up again there was a 9-4 consensus in favor of deleting the page. Since I'm one of the admins, I was pinged and asked to delete the page. If you're interested in some of this discussion, it can be found on the talk page of the main page at the very bottom. Talk:Main_Page. Sondenise (talk) 15:17, 17 September 2021 (UTC)


Template:Ruby

Memoria cards

I was noticing some cases where a memoria card contains a particular character, but that character's page does not reference the memoria card, so I was thinking of going through to track down all such cases that I can find. However, before I can do that, I have a few questions...

  1. Is there some logic to how memoria cards are ordered on a character's page? Is it just alphabetical by name?
I try to sort them by alphabetical order. Sondenise (talk) 01:35, 10 April 2022 (UTC)
  1. What's the best way to deal with alternate versions of characters, and dual units?
    Should a memoria featuring swimsuit Iroha be included on Iroha's main page?
    Should a memoria featuring Holy Mami be included on Mami's main page?
    Should a memoria featuring Rumour Tsuruno be featured on Tsuruno's main page?
    Should a memoria featuring Iroha-chan be featured on Iroha's main page?
    Should a memoria featuring Delivery Girl Felicia be featured on Felicia's main page?
    Should a memoria featuring Ultimate Madoka be featured on Madoka's main page?
    Should a memoria featuring doppel Kyouko be featured on Kyouko's main page?
    I imagine this is a complex question... my instinct would suggest the answer be "no" in the case of Iroha-chan or Ultimate Madoka but "yes" in most of the other cases.
Originally I tended to leave the memoria unique to the alternate units on their respective page if only because some units have so many alts or are featured in so many memoria that it would really increase the page length. That said, maybe we should move their memorias to their own page or put it under a collapsible table to help cut down on the page length. If we do it like that, then I would agree that we should include their alt version memorias on their vanilla unit page with the exception of the PAPA units since those guys are basically their own universe and fairly self-contained.

Also, based on this new Category:Magia Record Memoria Cards and comparing the count with the other Magia Record wiki, there seems to be one card entirely missing. I have no way to determine which one it could be, though, as the category is sorted by filename and the filenames are all over the place.

I wonder how we could track it down. If there's a way of tagging or letting me know which ones need to be renamed to their original file names I'm willing to move them all for the sake of uniformity and so we can track down that last memoria and get it up on the site. Sondenise (talk) 01:35, 10 April 2022 (UTC)

One last thing: I found three card images that are duplicates. In particular, this one exists in both JPEG and WEBP format for some reason:

This is probably a case where more than one person uploaded the image and then since it's different formats they didn't get the warning. I can delete the extra file, just tag the one you want me to delete with the deletion tag.
Since you are going through the memorias, do you think it would be too much to add a tag for the passive/active memos and another tag for 1*,2*, 3*,4*?
On another note entirely, since we now have the "akuma" typing for magireco, would it be possible to write the template so we have an "other" typing and then put a "|displayname=" where it just displays a name for the typing but it's still categorized as "other"? I think this might take care of the one off types like Nagisa, Nagisa alt, Ult. Madoka-senpai and one or two i've forgotten.
Thank you very much for you hard work and lemme know what I can do to help. Sondenise (talk) 01:35, 10 April 2022 (UTC)