Talk:Madoka Magica Mobage Characters: Difference between revisions

From Puella Magi Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
OK, I'm not going to do an edit war, so here's my compromise proposal:
OK, I'm not going to do an edit war, so here's my compromise proposal:
 
:(merged into main article in revision as of 02:00, 14 January 2012 (UTC), removed from here for readability)
{|class="wikitable" style="width:100%;text-align:center;border:none;"
!colspan="84"|[[Characters|Main anime characters]] appearing
|-
|colspan="4" style="width:16.66%;"|[[File:Mobage New Years 01.jpg|100px|link=Madoka Kaname]]
|colspan="4" style="width:16.66%;"|[[File:Mobage New Years 05.jpg|100px|link=Homura Akemi]]
|colspan="4" style="width:16.66%;"|[[File:Mobage New Years 04.jpg|100px|link=Sayaka Miki]]
|colspan="4" style="width:16.66%;"|[[File:Mobage New Years 03.jpg|100px|link=Mami Tomoe]]
|colspan="4" style="width:16.66%;"|[[File:Mobage New Years 02.jpg|100px|link=Kyoko Sakura]]
|colspan="4" style="width:16.66%;"|
|-
|colspan="4"|'''[[Madoka Kaname]]'''
|colspan="4"|'''[[Homura Akemi]]'''
|colspan="4"|'''[[Sayaka Miki]]'''
|colspan="4"|'''[[Mami Tomoe]]'''
|colspan="4"|'''[[Kyoko Sakura]]'''
|colspan="4"|'''[[Kyubey]]'''
|-
|colspan="36" style="border-left:none;border-right:none;padding:3px;"|
|-
!colspan="36"|[[Characters|Supporting anime characters]] appearing
|-
|colspan="4" style="width:11.11%"|[[Kyousuke Kamijou]]
|colspan="4" style="width:11.11%"|[[Hitomi Shizuki]]
|-
|colspan="36" style="border-left:none;border-right:none;padding:3px;"|
|-
!colspan="36"|Original Characters
|-
|colspan="4" style="width:20%;|[[File:Mobile Game Elise.jpg|100px]]
|colspan="4" style="width:20%;|[[File:Mobile Game New Girl 2.jpg|100px]]
|colspan="4" style="width:20%;|[[File:Mobile Game New Girl 3.jpg|100px]]
|colspan="4" style="width:20%;|[[File:Mobile Game New Girl 4.jpg|100px]]
|-
|colspan="4" style="width:20%;|'''Elise'''<br />
|colspan="4" style="width:20%;|'''Claire'''<br />
|colspan="4" style="width:20%;|'''Hiyori'''<br />
|colspan="4" style="width:20%;|'''Komachi'''<br />
|-
!colspan="36"|Original Witches
|-
|colspan="6" style="width:20%;|[[File:Mobage New Witch 01.jpg|175px]]
|colspan="6" style="width:20%;|[[File:Mobage New Witch 02.jpg|175px]]
|colspan="6" style="width:20%;|[[File:Mobage New Witch 03.jpg|175px]]
|colspan="6" style="width:20%;|[[File:Mobage New Witch 04.jpg|175px]]
|-
|colspan="6" style="width:20%;|'''The witch of sewing'''<br />
|colspan="6" style="width:20%;|'''The witch of springtime'''<br />
|colspan="6" style="width:20%;|'''The witch of giraffes'''<br />
|colspan="6" style="width:20%;|'''The witch of ??'''<br />
|}
 
Of course, the current version will look better on eg. 1366x768 screen with maximized browser window. But it's good to have the page look nice in narrower browsers, too. It's true, virtually every modern computer has a screen with at least 1280 horizontal pixels. But there are smartphones (usually 800px or less), tablets (usually 1024px), and people who use half-width browser windows on fullHD screens (me :P). So I feel it's vital to have the minimum browser window width at which the site looks neat and doesn't need horizontal scrollbar at somewhere around 900-1000px. --[[User:KFYatek|kFYatek]] 01:21, 14 January 2012 (UTC)
Of course, the current version will look better on eg. 1366x768 screen with maximized browser window. But it's good to have the page look nice in narrower browsers, too. It's true, virtually every modern computer has a screen with at least 1280 horizontal pixels. But there are smartphones (usually 800px or less), tablets (usually 1024px), and people who use half-width browser windows on fullHD screens (me :P). So I feel it's vital to have the minimum browser window width at which the site looks neat and doesn't need horizontal scrollbar at somewhere around 900-1000px. --[[User:KFYatek|kFYatek]] 01:21, 14 January 2012 (UTC)
:Fine by me.  The reason I didn't like it smaller before is you couldn't clearly make out the witch and I didn't see an issue with the original size of the pics, since they don't take up much space.  I'm sure many pages on the wiki probably look terrible on a small monitor, but I'm not one to check and fix it so they do. --[[User:Randomanon|randomanon]] 01:27, 14 January 2012 (UTC)
:Fine by me.  The reason I didn't like it smaller before is you couldn't clearly make out the witch and I didn't see an issue with the original size of the pics, since they don't take up much space.  I'm sure many pages on the wiki probably look terrible on a small monitor, but I'm not one to check and fix it so they do. --[[User:Randomanon|randomanon]] 01:27, 14 January 2012 (UTC)
::Actually, with a browser window around 1000px wide, the layout feels just fine. I remember tweaking only with one of the other character sheets, and AFAIR the [[Weapons]] page. All the regular article are fine like that. Another reason to keep it like that ;)
OK, so as you're fine with it, I've made the change in the main article. --[[User:KFYatek|kFYatek]] 02:02, 14 January 2012 (UTC)

Revision as of 02:02, 14 January 2012

OK, I'm not going to do an edit war, so here's my compromise proposal:

(merged into main article in revision as of 02:00, 14 January 2012 (UTC), removed from here for readability)

Of course, the current version will look better on eg. 1366x768 screen with maximized browser window. But it's good to have the page look nice in narrower browsers, too. It's true, virtually every modern computer has a screen with at least 1280 horizontal pixels. But there are smartphones (usually 800px or less), tablets (usually 1024px), and people who use half-width browser windows on fullHD screens (me :P). So I feel it's vital to have the minimum browser window width at which the site looks neat and doesn't need horizontal scrollbar at somewhere around 900-1000px. --kFYatek 01:21, 14 January 2012 (UTC)

Fine by me. The reason I didn't like it smaller before is you couldn't clearly make out the witch and I didn't see an issue with the original size of the pics, since they don't take up much space. I'm sure many pages on the wiki probably look terrible on a small monitor, but I'm not one to check and fix it so they do. --randomanon 01:27, 14 January 2012 (UTC)
Actually, with a browser window around 1000px wide, the layout feels just fine. I remember tweaking only with one of the other character sheets, and AFAIR the Weapons page. All the regular article are fine like that. Another reason to keep it like that ;)

OK, so as you're fine with it, I've made the change in the main article. --kFYatek 02:02, 14 January 2012 (UTC)