Episode revisions

From Puella Magi Wiki
Revision as of 20:34, 26 April 2011 by KFYatek (talk | contribs) (Episode 1 & 2 BD versions)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

The series was released several times over the time:

  • the original broadcasts on MBS and TBS
  • one week late broadcast on CBC
  • webcast on Nico Nico Douga, Showtime and AnimeOne
  • three months late broadcast on AT-X
  • DVD/BD release

This page is a work-in-progress attempt to list at least some of the changes made to the episodes in later revisions.

Episode 1

AT-X version

  • In the original broadcast, all the background music (most notably, Magia played during the prologue scene) is played slower and at a lower pitch. In the AT-X version (and reportedly the webcast version, too), this was corrected, causing the need for the tunes to be edited differently to fit the video.[1]
  • No differences in the video, voice acting or sound effects were spotted.
Comparison of dream sequence in original versions of Episode 1 and Episode 10. Blu-ray version of Episode 1 looks like Episode 10.

Blu-ray version

Those differences were pointed on Amimone☆Nikki, a Japanese fan's blog. See there for screenshot comparison.

  • The prologue scene was heavily modified, to keep it in line with Timeline 4 of Episode 10.
  • A version of opening sequence that debuted in Episode 6's broadcast version is used.
  • Direction of sunlight is changed in some shots of the walk to school.
  • Girls' shadows are drawn in more detail in other shots of the same scene.
  • Closeup shot of the teacher is re-animated.
  • During Homura's introduction, her name on the whiteboard is moved to be visible.
  • Sayaka's hairpin is added in some shots in the classroom.
  • Lighting is dimmed in Homura's high jump shot.
  • Likewise, some shots in the cafeteria are lit less intensively.
  • Lights glow in Kyubey chase scene is changed.
  • A fence is added before Madoka in the shot where she meets Kyubey.
  • Lines on Madoka's cheeks are less intense in a closeup shot of her afterwards.
  • The explosion in Gertrud's maze is animated completely differently.
  • Mami's Soul Gem is much smaller in her first shot.
  • Mami is lit differently in a shot before her transformation.
  • During Mami's transformation, Soul Gem has different shape and is glowing more intensively.
  • The episode has a proper ending sequence with an entirely new song ("Mata Ashita" by Aoi Yuuki).

Episode 2

Blu-ray version

Those differences were pointed on Amimone☆Nikki, a Japanese fan's blog. See there for screenshot comparison.

  • Reflections in the mirror during the bath scene are much brighter.
  • Interior of Mami's apartment is redesigned completely, with a round table and many stuff inside.
  • Mami's Soul Gem is bigger when she shows it to the second-years.
  • Some shots inside Mami's apartment have characters redrawn in addition to a completely different background.
  • Color of the sunset behind Mami's windows is different.
  • Madoka is visible in some of the shots of Junko before the window.
  • Shot of Mami's reflection in the table is zoomed out, showing much more detail.
  • Madoka's face is lit differently during a closeup shot in Mami's apartment.
  • Closeups of Mami's Soul Gem show a slightly different design of it.
  • Fence on the school rooftop has a different pattern.
  • Flash of Kyousuke's room now features a dark sunset or sunrise.
  • When the girls go on a witch hunt, the lighting is darker, and blooming cherry trees are replaced by dead trees. The bridges also have different designs.
  • The girl jumping off the bridge has darker hair.
  • The pavement in a subsequent shot is patterned.
  • In a shot before Mami takes down few Adelberts, the girls are lit differently.
  • A place before entrance to Gertrud's chamber looks different.
  • Gertrud's name (in runes) is written in a smaller and differently colored font.
  • Background Gertrud's chamber is slightly different. Witch's movements are also different.
  • The ending sequence is added, like in Episode 1.

Episode 4

AT-X version

  • Elly's Grief Seed is shown after the fight.

Episode 10

Episode 10 Nico Changes.jpg

Webcast version

See the image on the right for a visual comparison of the original MBS broadcast version and the revised webcast version.

  • When Madoka and Mami attack Izabel in her barrier, the original version has highly stylized black-and-white blobs. The revised version show more detailed laser beams.
  • One of the shots of Walpurgis Night in Timeline 1 is mirrored, compared to the original version.
  • Kyubey is removed from the scene when Madoka becomes a witch in Timeline 2.
  • The color scheme of the aforementioned Madoka's transformation into a witch is reversed - it was a white energy blob and black lightning in the original version, but it's a dark energy blob and a white lightning in the revised version.
  • During the battle with Oktavia von Seckendorff in Timeline 3, her full name (in runes) is shown. In the original version, only "Oktavia von" is readable: "Seckendorff" was misplaced off-screen, as seen by the tips of the O, R and F runes at the bottom edge of the screen.
  • Spots of grief in one of Homura's shots when she's making a promise to protect Madoka are timed differently.
  • Two first shots of Roberta's barrier are discolored.
  • Kriemhild Gretchen's name in Timeline 4 is shown (in runes).
  • A big tree is seen next to the platform where Homura and Kyubey stand after Madoka's transformation.
  • Homura is seen walking through the "tunnel of time" in shots where she was walking just on a dark background in the original version.

TBS/CBC version

As TBS and CBC haven't shown Episode 10 on the same week as MBS, it was shown in a one-and-half-hour-long block together with episodes 11 and 12. This revision contains few further differences:

  • The first shot of Walpurgis Night in Timeline 1 is mirrored as well.
  • In one of the shots when Homura practices her golf club skills on time-stop in Timeline 2, a rain droplet is added in front of the camera.
  • In another shot of the same scene, when the time flow is restored, the rain is heavier.
  • Oktavia von Seckendorff is shown moving just before the explosion that kills her. In earlier revisions, a still picture of her was shown.
  • When Homura approaches Madoka in Timeline 4, the light is turned on in Madoka's room.
  • The rotating platform Homura is standing on during the fight with Roberta is discolored in the first shot, so is her cage and the shot when it explodes.
  • The aforementioned explosion is brighter and has a glow effect to it.

Episode 11

Homura-chan... ;_;

Webcast version

  • Several shots in the shelter were added. One of them shows a replica of a satellite map made after the 2011 Sendai Earthquake.
  • A closeup shot of Homura's leg broken under a rock is added.

Those shots were not shown in the original broadcast version probably as a form of self-restraint censorship.

Annotations

  1. Although the slowed-down version of Magia was thought to be intentional by many, this is likely a production error in the original version. The difference in speed and pitch is equal to playing a digital recording recorded at the sample rate of 48000 Hz (common for studio recording, DVD/BD and broadcast) as 44100 Hz (used on audio CDs). It probably means that there was some mistake during some stage of distribution or editing of the music recordings. Pitch of background music has been also corrected for all subsequent episodes.